by ponyte » Tue Jul 07, 2020 5:46 pm
The Pony Express years had All-Americans, All SWC and many future NFL starters at every position. That's pretty stiff competition for players of any era.
Its very difficult to compare players with very different offensive and defensive schemes in differnt eras of the game.
Perhaps a better comparison is how many Pony Express (PE) players could adapt and play in a Jones, Morris, Dykes style offense and how many can adapt to the current more wide open defense.
Wide recievers in the PE era would be at a disadvantage though some starred in th NFL. Big Downhill O linemen might have some difficulties adapting though most were very athletic and could adapt (IMHO). I believe, for the most part Special teams would improve with PE era players just because the overall athleticism of those players is better than post DP players (in general, of course exceptions).
I think for the most part, many PE era diefensive players could adapt. We did have one All-American CB in John Simmons during the PE era. Have no doubt he could adapt.