Official Replay Thread (On Now on CBS-CS)

[mrydel]

That was a pretty pathetic display of officiating. The punt is the one that ticks me off the most since it was reviewed and they had the chance to get it right.

Could be wrong but I think the review was just to insure that the ball was recovered by WSU in the end zone. I am not certain the judgment of the "blocked into" call is reviewable.

[Stallion]

interesting because I thought that was unreviewable too

[Dooby]

I occur that wasn't a reviewable call.

Did we ever figure out where these refs were from? I half-wondered if it was a PAC-10 crew with CUSA replay officials and the replay crew was trying to find someday of reversing a ridiculous call.

[Dooby]

Finally found it

Referee: Steve Barth  •  Umpire: Ramon George  •  Linesman: Merrill Eason  •  Line judge: George Geiss  •  Back judge: Jabir Walker  •  Field judge: Glen Fucik  •  Side judge: Tony Meyer  •  Scorer: Steve Selby  • 

It is a C-USA crew. I hope we never see them again.

[mustangbill67]

That was a pretty pathetic display of officiating. The punt is the one that ticks me off the most since it was reviewed and they had the chance to get it right.

I may be wrong but I believe they cannot review the penalty or lack of penalty. All they can review is whether the recovery of the ball in the endzone was a touchdown.

[JasonB]

In person, I thought we were a much more athletic team than WSU and we were just keeping ourselves from dominating the game. On the replay, you couldn't see it as much, because you don't see as much off the ball. KP made lots of good, quick decisions in the second half, and will need to play that way for the entire TCU game to keep us in it.