Vitale wrote:White Helmet wrote:Easy there chief. We all know most TMEA All-staters at SMU go to Meadows and that rules out the Mustang Band.
Why can't they do both?
They could if Meadows professors didn't STRONGLY discourage them from doing so. In some cases, there have even been threats of losing their Music scholarship if they participate in the Band. They make arguments like "it ruins your embouchure" and "you don't have time because of your commitments to Meadows ensembles" -- which doesn't explain why almost every other Music School in the country actually REQUIRES at least a year or two participation in the school's marching band.
Vitale wrote:And has anyone ever clarified why the numbers have dwindled over the years, or why there aren't band scholarships? I love the Mustang Band, but it should be twice (at least) its current size. Used to be what, "99 guys and a doll" or somesuch? What's the membership now .... 40? Those who are in it do a terrific job, but SMU should give band scholarships, just like everyone else.
Where have you been? This is discussed ad nauseum every football season. There about 60-65 current bandsmen. Basically boils down to:
1. Scholarships -- while tuition has skyrocketed over the last 20 years, Mustang Band Scholarships have not increased to keep pace. Little university money is allocated to the Band. If you'd like to help (and see some statistics), go to
www.smubandpartnership.com.
2. The Demographic of the Average SMU Student -- Ever wonder why a school with a top notch football program like HPHS has such a teeny band?
Studies show that as income goes up, participation in high school marching bands go down. Band is a middle class (or lower) activity, and with the cost of tuition up, the Band has an increasingly smaller pool to recruit from, and combined with less scholarship money, it's harder to get the middle class band kids who would otherwise go to state schools here.
3. We don't win much. Sometimes recruiting and retention is all about incentives like fun road trips, Bowl Games, tourney appearances, etc. Conference USA will help because the Band will be able to travel to more away games. The other stuff is up to the teams. It's the same reason why it is so hard for us to have consistently great spirit teams and mascots even though I'd wager there are TONS of students who were cheerleaders, etc. in high school. People don't try out because they don't see what's in it for them in exchange for working a little harder than your average SMU student.
4. Apathy is cool at SMU -- It's just not cool to care. At many schools, being a cheerleader or even, yes, in the band is a badge of honor (see dotting the I at Ohio State or the roar of the early arriving Texas Tech crowd when the band comes on the field for PRE-game). Here, it is often a sign of caring too much, i.e. being a geek.