PonyFans.com

I thought I'd start a positive, fun thread on who everyone thinks are the top 5 recruits in this class.

Here's my first stab:

1 - Gehrig Dieter
2 - Seaver Myers
3 - Daijuan Stewart
4 - Prescott Line
5 - Lincoln Richard

* Christian Holloway (not this class I know but might as well be), Dieter, Roundtree, and Middleton (not this class as well but might as well) are all already on campus and enrolled I believe and will participate in Spring ball (I think).

I choose to move forward on who we have and roll with these future All BE gamers - next year we can do this again. Now, on to 2012 season!

Aw, c'mon...

Let's include Garrett Gilbert in there for fun.

austinponie wrote:Aw, c'mon...

Let's include Garrett Gilbert in there for fun.

OK, I'm game ...

1 - GG (5 star, top 10 QB in country, from TX, multiple BC offers, chose SMU over UT)
2 - Gehrig Dieter (Parade All-American, broke several high school receiving records)
3 - Seaver Myers (6'6", 290 lb beast chose SMU over offer by aTm, from TX)
4 - Daijuan Stewart (speedster who will excel in slot, from Louisiana, chose SMU over multiple BCS offers)
5 - Prescott Line (Parade All-American)

*6 - Lincoln Richard (chose SMU over multiple BCS offers, integral part of 2011 TX HS championship team, his teammate from same team also committed to SMU)
*7 - Neil Burcham (co-MVP Elite 11 QB camp, from Arkansas)

Middleton enrolled in Augest and counts towards the 2011 class not this one.

Top 5 in this class IMO are

1. Randolph
2. Neroes
3. Richard
4. Richardson (at slot)
5. Justice

1. Seaver Myers
2. Lincoln Richard
3. Daijuan Stewart
4. Neal Burcham
5. Eli Nabushoshi

Honorable Mention: Sam Rice & Shak Randolph

When Ty Law announces SMU on Wednesday, I will be excited...Think he is gonna be a good player.

1. C. Holloway
2. C. Brigg
3. L. Richard
4. T. Law (when or if he signs)
5. D. Roundtree

Dieter is a big, competitive kid which I like.

ojaipony wrote:No love for Dieter, huh? Are we concerned about his speed? That's my biggest concern with him but a big, competitive kid otherwise which I like.

Who are your other 4?

Rebel10 wrote:

ojaipony wrote:No love for Dieter, huh? Are we concerned about his speed? That's my biggest concern with him but a big, competitive kid otherwise which I like.

Who are your other 4?

See top post.

CoxMustangFan wrote:

ojaipony wrote:No love for Dieter, huh? Are we concerned about his speed? That's my biggest concern with him but a big, competitive kid otherwise which I like.

You're certainly entitled to your opinion, but there are a couple of things that concern me about him (that I'm not going to post on a public message board). Here's to hoping I'm wrong and he has a huge career at SMU!!

I hear you, Cox. I might whack my previous post about him now that you got me thinking about it.

ojaipony wrote:

CoxMustangFan wrote:

ojaipony wrote:No love for Dieter, huh? Are we concerned about his speed? That's my biggest concern with him but a big, competitive kid otherwise which I like.

You're certainly entitled to your opinion, but there are a couple of things that concern me about him (that I'm not going to post on a public message board). Here's to hoping I'm wrong and he has a huge career at SMU!!

I hear you, Cox. I might whack my previous post about him now that you got me thinking about it.

Who would you replace him with?

Rebel10 wrote:
Who would you replace him with?

I'd keep him where I had him. I was talking about whacking my post asking about why others would exclude him from top 5. Until/unless otherwise, he's definitely top 5 IMHO.

whatever happened to the big kid from germany that was going to by our next great linebacker?

I think he will be a senior in high school this coming year.