How should the one-and-dones be handled?

[CoxMustangFan]

OBF, gun to head to win a NC, which eight player team do you pick:

Team A

#4 (leaves after one year), #59, #101, #149, #251, #279, #315, #329

Team B

#31, #49, #69, #99, #129, #139, #142, #150

[OhioBrownFan]

OBF, gun to head to win a NC, which eight player team do you pick:

Team A

#4 (leaves after one year), #59, #101, #149, #251, #279, #315, #329

Team B

#31, #49, #69, #99, #129, #139, #142, #150

I understand what you're saying man, I really do. I'm just saying that you need the big time talents to win it. FWIW, rarely do anything after #120 ever pan out to be very good players anyways. SMU will shortly only be taking top 100, probably in 2015. It's a null argument, ideally you want a blend of experience but those top 10 players every year really put teams over the top. And they don't always leave. Anyways, this is off-topic from the original argument, I'd rather not see coaches have to choose. Teams that pull a top 5 player typically got top 75 players surrounding him too.

[CoxMustangFan]

Teams that pull a top 5 player typically got top 75 players surrounding him too.

Bingo. That's the real point.

[hoopmanx]

You need 2 or 3 kids that have NBA careers ahead of them, not necessarily McD AAs out of high school, to make deep runs.