PonyFans.com

That appears to be a problem the DMN had when it came to covering what Ronnie Morgan's status was with us. Of course, he signed with La. Tech.

Calvin didn't follow DMN policy. When looking in the archives, I could find nothing to suggest that Morgan said he committed to us. The only things were in the story when Tubbs got fired, it suggested that Morgan was coming to take his visit the following weekend.

Then in the sidebar story when Doherty was hired, Calvin quoted SOC coach James Mays saying Morgan committed to us. That's a big NO NO.

The DMN has a policy on commitments that if it is going to print them, it must come from the athlete NOT the coach or family member.

So based on what we know, it was not reported that Morgan committed to us. Maybe his visit could have sealed a commitment but that was off since Tubbs was fired.

If Calvin is pushing the DISD coaching agenda with the Tubbs situation, he should have been more careful to write one thing and then write something else. He needed to get it from Ronnie. He created more confusion on this than anything else.

And I for one, don't buy into commitments heard through the grapvine. They mean something when they are reported in the newspaper or any other media outlet with the athlete talking about it.

Best regards,

I'm pretty sure you are the one with an agenda. SMU's chances of signing Morgan over Louisiana Tech(where he eventually signed) with Tubbs as Coach were very very good. He didn't report that Morgan had committed but that Mays said he had committed. This is not uncommon AT ALL in recruiting.

Honestly, who cares? The fact of the matter is the guy didn't sign with us. It's over.Done.Let's just move on.

[deleted]. The first confirmed report on this site concerning the commitment of a player we offered and visited the school is plainly relevant. Why don't you go talk about the best Burgers in town over on the other link.

Dont try to ruin stallions grumpy party by saying what he lives for is not important.

Stallion wrote:[deleted]. The first confirmed report on this site concerning the commitment of a player we offered and visited the school is plainly relevant. Why don't you go talk about the best Burgers in town over on the other link.

Yet again, big boy stallion showing his class........

Sounds like Big10 is a DMN employee, if he's citing company policy.

Regardless, to suggest Calvin Watkins is "pushing the DISD agenda" is amusing, but ridiculous. He has absolutely no reason to. The fact is that if Mays told Calvin that Darrell Arthur was coming to SMU, we wouldn't be questioning Calvin's connections -- we'd be nominating him for a Pulitzer for getting the story we all want to hear.

I can't think of a single reason to doubt that Mays told Calvin that Morgan had committed to SMU.

Did Morgan sign with LA Tech before or after Doh. If after, I wonder if Doh had any interest in Morgan or if he believed he could do better.

Did Morgan sign with LA Tech before or after Doh. If after, I wonder if Doh had any interest in Morgan or if he believed he could do better.

....there ain't anything left unless he goes the Division 1A transfer, late qualifier or JUCOs attempting to graduate route. Morgan would have been a nice not great pickup. It may be that SMU has self imposed scholarship restrictions upon itself.

mustangbill67 wrote:Did Morgan sign with LA Tech before or after Doh. If after, I wonder if Doh had any interest in Morgan or if he believed he could do better.

After Tubbs, before Coach Down & Doherty.

Stallion wrote:It may be that SMU has self imposed scholarship restrictions upon itself.

Two scholarships would seem to be the logical self-imposed penalty.

"Coach Down & Doherty"?

Very nice, Corso

PonyPower wrote:Sounds like Big10 is a DMN employee, if he's citing company policy.

Regardless, to suggest Calvin Watkins is "pushing the DISD agenda" is amusing, but ridiculous. He has absolutely no reason to. The fact is that if Mays told Calvin that Darrell Arthur was coming to SMU, we wouldn't be questioning Calvin's connections -- we'd be nominating him for a Pulitzer for getting the story we all want to hear.

I can't think of a single reason to doubt that Mays told Calvin that Morgan had committed to SMU.

This post is kind of funny. I am about as big a defender of the DMN as there is, but anybody that thinks reporters, even the the beat writers, don't have agendas is fooling themselves.

Edit: The better question is why does the DMN have the policy of confirming commitments with the player (and they do, it is on their website.)? The reason is coaches, family members, everybody, have their own agendas, too. And does anyone want to doubt that Mays has an agenda?

Morgan did not sign before Doherty became coach-he signed I believe last Thursday.