Baylor's Bush library plan offered far more land, amenities than SMU's
09:40 AM CDT on Monday, August 17, 2009
By MARJORIE KORN / The Dallas Morning News
[email protected]Baylor University lost to SMU in the race to host George W. Bush's presidential library, despite offering more land, more buildings and more amenities, newly released records show.
Among the attractions the Waco school sketched out for the complex: an outdoor concert venue, a multi-use conference center, an IMAX theater, an on-site fishing lake, a Little League baseball field and a riverside boat dock.
In its pitch to the Bush selection panel in 2005, Baylor placed the library and museum on 150 acres along the Brazos River, buffering it from urban noise and congestion – worries that some Dallas homeowners already have with the library at SMU.
Mark Langdale, head of the Bush Foundation, the nonprofit raising money to run the library, said last week that the SMU plan may be more reserved but it befits the project's goal, which is to create a place for learning.
Architecturally, he said, "the library is going to be more modest than people expect, but it's going to be for a serious purpose. It fits into an academic environment."
Baylor, which gigged SMU during the competition for being too cramped to showcase the library, congratulated its rival last year for winning the "spirited but honorable" matchup.
Southern Methodist Universitywas always considered the front-runner because of the Bushes' academic and personal ties: The couple had many friends and political supporters at SMU, Laura Bush went to school there and was a board trustee, they lived in Dallas before Bush became governor, and they returned to the city after the presidency.
Tommye Lou Davis who chaired Baylor's library committee, said it was worth trying. "We didn't focus as much on our underdog status," but rather "what would be meaningful" for the Waco area and the Bushes, whose ranch in Crawford is 20 miles away, she said.
Now, she said, "We look forward to visiting President Bush's library one of these days."
More than a half-dozen schools sought the project, which backers view as a prestigious landmark, scholarly attraction and tourist site.
Laura Bush said no one had an inside edge. "I ended up deciding on SMU for a lot of reasons, and none of it had to do with Baylor," she told a Waco TV station in January.
"SMU was my school and, of course, I was interested because of that, but also it's a good location in Dallas and on a metro stop," she said, referring to DART's Mockingbird Station across North Central Expressway.
Key differences
Over the years, Baylor released a few general details of its plan but not, until recently, the feature-laden presentation it gave the site slection committee, composed of Bush associates. That's partly because the school indirectly was tangled up in a property lawsuit between SMU and a condo owner – a dispute settled last month.
Here, based on Baylor's 106-page proposal, are key differences between its offer and SMU's:
•Baylor had 150 acres for the complex along the Brazos. SMU is putting the library on a 32-acre tract on the eastern edge of campus along the expressway.
•Baylor's architects, HOK, the firm that designed George H.W. Bush's presidential center at Texas A&M University, proposed five options, all with the library and museum, a conference center, academic classrooms and the baseball diamond – a tribute to the younger Bush's fondness for the game.
Each of the options had separate features, such as an outdoor amphitheater, retail stores, restaurants, the fishing lake, a barbecue pavilion and a dock for boats and water taxis.
In contrast, the latest SMU site plan depicts a single large building, one side for the library and museum, and the other for a policy institute. It is surrounded by a parklike setting with foot paths and, in one corner, athletic fields.
Langdale, who was not involved in the decision to chose SMU, said the land there is spacious enough.
•Baylor's sites each had three and as many as five parking lots. "Waco is a place where people will flock without creating gridlock," Baylor said.
Langdale said a traffic analysis for the SMU site will be completed by the end of the month.
Recently, SMU and foundation officials have tried to appease nearby homeowners concerned about parking overflow, traffic tie-ups and other possible disruptions.
Langdale said the policy center is SMU's stand-out feature. He also touted a 5,000 square-foot temporary exhibit gallery in the museum.
Groundbreaking is scheduled for late next year, and the museum is expected to open in 2013.