Trivia: Best RB you ever seen live in College and Pro

[ponyfan08]

Earl Campbell when healthy

He gave as good as he got!

The guy was a stud.

[gostangs]

college - Dickerson - it is hard to describe how fun it was to watch him. That stride seemed like 5 yds at a time, and it seemed effortless - and his upper body was like a statue - it never moved.

for Pro i would say Emmit - just shear determination.

[ponyboy]

Eric Dickerson hands down. Wish the youngsters could have seen him. He'd still blow away the NFL

[Maryland78]

Gale Sayers was amazing...

[Stallion]

Dickerson
Earl Campbell

everybody else. Roosevelt Leaks wasn't too bad either before his knee injury-342 yards rushing, 359 yards Total Offense against SMU in 1973. (He was pissed after 3 first half fumbles). People forget but Leaks was 3rd in the Heisman as a Junior before he was injured as a Senior

[Stallion]

Classic highlites of 1973 game which SMU lead 14-0 but Texas scored 42 unanswered points in final 23 minutes. Mustang greats Oscar Roan, Freeman Johns, Rickey Wesson, Alvin Maxson, Wayne Morris, Henry Sheppard-isn't Jim "Hacksaw" Duggan in there too?


http://www.blinkx.com/watch-video/1973- ... R3IWIm379Q

[ojaipony]

Xavier Crawford. And I made the mistake of trying to tackle him once.

[TWALV33]

I'd have to say single performance that I've seen might have to go to Matt Forte when he lit us up. I think he had like 300+ yds or something insane. Granted I've seen some better players, but that single performance was crazy

[blackoutpony]

Being from San Diego, I got to see LT light it up for years. He was downright unstoppable.

Adrian Peterson after than.

After that, just because of how fun he was to watch and where he ranks all time in rushing yards, Jerome Bettis

[PSCA]

That’s the hardest thing to do in any sport … list who was the best. Different eras, training, nutrition etc etc.

NFL
1) Jim Brown
2) Gayle Sayers
3) Barry Sanders
4) Emmet Smith
5) ED
6) Earl Campbell
7) AP in a few years
There is another name that belongs here … but he can rot in jail

College

1) Same a #8
2) Ricky Williams
3) Hershel Walker
4) Archie Griffin
5) Billy Simms
6) Ricky Bell

[ponyboy]

You left #19 off your college list. You're right that OJ needs to be on the list.

[PlanoStang]

Classic highlites of 1973 game which SMU lead 14-0 but Texas scored 42 unanswered points in final 23 minutes. Mustang greats Oscar Roan, Freeman Johns, Rickey Wesson, Alvin Maxson, Wayne Morris, Henry Sheppard-isn't Jim "Hacksaw" Duggan in there too?

I remember feeling great for about 2.5 quarters of that game. We were going to beat Texas!

Remember the DMN's sports page heading the next day.

S.M.U. springs Leaks

Oh yeah....Dickerson best back I've ever seen in person over Campbell, Leaks, Line, Mike
Richardson, and Herschell Walker.

[Pony ^]

Ricky or Peterson. Wildcard: SHAWNBREY MCNEAL.

[Pony ^]

Jamaal Charles is a good one also...especially with his Td run against OU where everyone in the stadium thought he was tackled only to break it for 60 yards

[lwjr]

Earl Campbell in College
Walter Payton and Barry Sims (tie) in the pros. - Those two played on some pretty bad teams for the most part of their careers. I was glad to see Payton win a Super Bowl even though Dikta did not give him a chance to score a TD and instead gave it to the large tub of goo known as, The Fridge.