Page 2 of 6

Re: SMU offers 4-star CA QB

Posted: Tue Feb 25, 2014 9:35 pm
by mrydel
The cynic in me says he could be an academic question mark. By offering and then not getting due to academics, June could blame the school for not letting him get the players he wants, even though no one else could either. Someone convince me I am way off base because I do not like thinking this way.

Re: SMU offers 4-star CA QB

Posted: Tue Feb 25, 2014 10:04 pm
by blackoutpony
East Coast Mustang wrote:BOP is posting blackout again. It's odd that he doesn't have offers but he's a 4-star on Rivals and 88 on 247- I'd take him. We've "signed" one 4-star Rivals guy in the JJ era I believe- Moreland- and he never made it on campus.
Sober as your mother. I haven't seem the kid play, neither have you, so who's to say if he's Tom Brady or they confused him with someone else and he sucks.

I'm just going with what's on paper. He has no offers. June is NEVER ahead of the power curve.

It's an easy way to say he's recruiting harder if no one else is interested.i can see it now.......

JJ "Hey, you guys, I got a 4* QB"
COC "what's his name?"
JJ "His name? That Cali kid I think"
COC " he has zero FBS offers June....."
JJ " it wasn't that other people didn't want to offer him, it was that they knew that he wanted to be with a QB guru and wouldn't beat me out. I mean if I was a NFL GM, I would've taken Stephen Kaiser in the first round"

Re: SMU offers 4-star CA QB

Posted: Tue Feb 25, 2014 10:41 pm
by East Coast Mustang
blackoutpony wrote:
East Coast Mustang wrote:BOP is posting blackout again. It's odd that he doesn't have offers but he's a 4-star on Rivals and 88 on 247- I'd take him. We've "signed" one 4-star Rivals guy in the JJ era I believe- Moreland- and he never made it on campus.
Sober as your mother. I haven't seem the kid play, neither have you, so who's to say if he's Tom Brady or they confused him with someone else and he sucks.

I'm just going with what's on paper. He has no offers. June is NEVER ahead of the power curve.

It's an easy way to say he's recruiting harder if no one else is interested.i can see it now.......

JJ "Hey, you guys, I got a 4* QB"
COC "what's his name?"
JJ "His name? That Cali kid I think"
COC " he has zero FBS offers June....."
JJ " it wasn't that other people didn't want to offer him, it was that they knew that he wanted to be with a QB guru and wouldn't beat me out. I mean if I was a NFL GM, I would've taken Stephen Kaiser in the first round"
Stallion can speak to this better than I can, but if he enrolled here and his Rivals rank stays the same (~250) he'd be one of the highest rated players- if not the highest- to sign here since the DP. Stallion laid out the reasons why he might not have as many offers yet but I bet he will have more soon- us getting in there early and offering first can't hurt though. He's been Tweeting/Retweeting about it all day: https://twitter.com/kkearns15

Re: SMU offers 4-star CA QB

Posted: Tue Feb 25, 2014 10:48 pm
by blackoutpony
Like I said, he could be good, he could be a dud, I have no idea, his lack of any single offer is just what's concerning to me for such a "highly rated" player.

Re: SMU offers 4-star CA QB

Posted: Tue Feb 25, 2014 11:30 pm
by Mustangsabu
blackoutpony wrote:
birddogger wrote:You guys are ripping the staff for extending an offer to a 4*? Un. Frickin. Believable! Criticize all day for lack of effort, but not for this!
You can look at it two ways, we offered a 4* star kid or we offered a kid with no offers.

As has been reiterated many times on here, judging offers as opposed to stars is a much better way to gauge a players ability and their prospects. If you take a 2* with 20 P5 offers and a 5* with 1 P5 offer, I'm inclined to pick the 2*
How about judging a player when he sees the field.

Re: SMU offers 4-star CA QB

Posted: Tue Feb 25, 2014 11:31 pm
by Buddha
This is ridiculous. JJ does stuff we all wonder about, no secret there. But for all of the [deleted] and moaning about not going after guys with stars, people are going to get upset now with an offer to a 4 star QB? Apparently JJ is in the "damned if you do, damned if you don't" pool. Some people refuse to be satisfied with anything if it interrupts the hate-mongering. Maybe this kid doesn't have a lot of offers because he has a job that prevents him from going to camps and junior days. I'm with 86. He'll get more offers.

Re: SMU offers 4-star CA QB

Posted: Tue Feb 25, 2014 11:45 pm
by East Coast Mustang
Buddha wrote:This is ridiculous. JJ does stuff we all wonder about, no secret there. But for all of the [deleted] and moaning about not going after guys with stars, people are going to get upset now with an offer to a 4 star QB? Apparently JJ is in the "damned if you do, damned if you don't" pool. Some people refuse to be satisfied with anything if it interrupts the hate-mongering. Maybe this kid doesn't have a lot of offers because he has a job that prevents him from going to camps and junior days. I'm with 86. He'll get more offers.
This.

Re: SMU offers 4-star CA QB

Posted: Wed Feb 26, 2014 12:58 am
by Pony147
Here is an interesting tweet:

Langley ‏@_IsaiahLangley 12h
Congrats to my QB Kyle Kearns @kkearns15 for his first offer from SMU #PackageDeal #DoubleTrouble

Isaiah is a 4* ATH also from Foothill HS who also picked up an offer from SMU today...

His list (per Rivals):

Arizona St, Boise St, California, Colorado, Florida St, Georgia, Houston, Miami (FL), Mississippi, Mississippi St, Notre Dame, Oklahoma, Oregon, Oregon St, San Jose St, UCLA, USC, Utah, Washington, and Washington St.

Re: SMU offers 4-star CA QB

Posted: Wed Feb 26, 2014 1:14 am
by SMU 86
Buddha wrote:This is ridiculous. JJ does stuff we all wonder about, no secret there. But for all of the [deleted] and moaning about not going after guys with stars, people are going to get upset now with an offer to a 4 star QB? Apparently JJ is in the "damned if you do, damned if you don't" pool. Some people refuse to be satisfied with anything if it interrupts the hate-mongering. Maybe this kid doesn't have a lot of offers because he has a job that prevents him from going to camps and junior days. I'm with 86. He'll get more offers.
True, but Blackoutpony was right in calling me out. I think I did say that Severt would get more offers and he did not. If he doesn't get more then it would be a concern at that point. It may not be hate but concern.

Re: SMU offers 4-star CA QB

Posted: Wed Feb 26, 2014 1:23 am
by Stallion
The market for 6-5 QBs who run 4.8 or 4.9 -isn't what it used to be. Just a fact that when so many teams are running spread offenses that many teams are looking for Dual Threat-QBs. Just a numbers game that might return big dividends

Re: SMU offers 4-star CA QB

Posted: Wed Feb 26, 2014 7:18 am
by Rebel10
Buddha wrote: . Maybe this kid doesn't have a lot of offers because he has a job that prevents him from going to camps and junior days.
You don't have to go to junior days and camps to get offers. Must coaching staffs go to high school football games or Spring practice to actually see them play. If Rivals knows about this kid then other coaching staff especially on the west coast do as well.

Re: SMU offers 4-star CA QB

Posted: Wed Feb 26, 2014 9:46 am
by leopold
THE LAST THING WE NEED TO WORRY ABOUT IS THE QB.

If there is ANYTHING June Jones has proven he can do while at SMU it is take a Quarterback and make him productive. JJ McDermitt, Kyle Padron, UT's washout, it doesn't matter, the QB will be turned into a darkhorse NFL candidate.

When was the last time we got a 4* OL to look at us, or a 4* DL, at least one who isn't looking to transfer? That is what worries me, not who is under center.

Re: SMU offers 4-star CA QB

Posted: Wed Feb 26, 2014 9:49 am
by Rebel10
leopold wrote:THE LAST THING WE NEED TO WORRY ABOUT IS THE QB.

If there is ANYTHING June Jones has proven he can do while at SMU it is take a Quarterback and make him productive. JJ McDermitt, Kyle Padron, UT's washout, it doesn't matter, the QB will be turned into a darkhorse NFL candidate.

When was the last time we got a 4* OL to look at us, or a 4* DL, at least one who isn't looking to transfer? That is what worries me, not who is under center.
Bo Levi?

Re: SMU offers 4-star CA QB

Posted: Wed Feb 26, 2014 9:49 am
by Rebel10
"I got an offer from SMU," explained Kearns. "It came out of nowhere, just a normal day at school and I had never talked to them before. I went to school and my head coach told me that he wanted me to call a coach so I could get my first offer."

Re: SMU offers 4-star CA QB

Posted: Wed Feb 26, 2014 9:50 am
by East Coast Mustang
leopold wrote:THE LAST THING WE NEED TO WORRY ABOUT IS THE QB.

If there is ANYTHING June Jones has proven he can do while at SMU it is take a Quarterback and make him productive. JJ McDermitt, Kyle Padron, UT's washout, it doesn't matter, the QB will be turned into a darkhorse NFL candidate.

When was the last time we got a 4* OL to look at us, or a 4* DL, at least one who isn't looking to transfer? That is what worries me, not who is under center.
Disagree- JJ's inability to groom a QB during his tenure here has been perplexing, esp. after what he did with Brennan and Chang at Hawaii. Our teams have only been as successful as the defense during June's time here, and I wouldn't have expected that.