PonyFans.com

ebrooks11 wrote:This late in the game and only one offer means he is not a legit 4 star.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I537 using Tapatalk

If you look at some other kids who are 4 stars (but not on any national list) and they don't have any big time offers, that should tell you that something else is in play because I truly believe these services, who are typically pretty close in their ratings, would not have these ratings if the kids just flat out stunk.

Not pertaining to Kearns but academics are a part of it, they could also be coming off major injuries (so schools are slow to pull the trigger and may want kids to camp to see if they are really healthy) or it could be the caliber of competition they are facing in high school that earns the hesitation.

There's a kid in south texas who had committed to texas but is not anymore because of the coaching change. I can't remember his name, but he's a 4 star and doesn't have any offers I think.

I agree that these things are head scratchers. I'm not defending SMU here. Maybe the staff is taking a chance on him with this offer. I don't know. I'm simply offering a reason as to why something looks the way it does. But we've also seen where some of their other QB arrivals have been pretty awful. So who knows.

Im guessing the reason he is dropping out of the 250 is because Rivals is figuring out that maybe their rating of him wasnt exactly accurate. I base my giddiness on future prospects solely on their offers. The stars mean absolutely nothing to me. i would much rather play the odds and offer a QB that alot of schools want other than being the only school to offer a kid because our coach see something that no one else does. We have seen how that has worked out.

yeah but you need to account for the many early commits who then actually shut down recruiting early.

Stallion wrote:yeah but you need to account for the many early commits who then actually shut down recruiting early.

Well, if Kyler Murray chooses Oregon over A&M on Wednesday, then that one is not over.