Page 2 of 4

Re: Potential Stidham destination that isn't Baylor...

Posted: Sun Dec 14, 2014 1:41 pm
by Pony Boss
Most likely not coming to SMU but good to be in the conversation. Loving the Chad Morris effect.
BTW the names of the recruits that wanted it to be kept down low are on the pay boards as ponyscott mentioned.

Re: Potential Stidham destination that isn't Baylor...

Posted: Sun Dec 14, 2014 5:15 pm
by ender3
For those looking for the tweet, it was @craigsmoak, not @davidsmoak.

There's a lot of noise, nothing concrete.

Re: Potential Stidham destination that isn't Baylor...

Posted: Sun Dec 14, 2014 6:22 pm
by Chnash318
Pony Boss wrote:Most likely not coming to SMU but good to be in the conversation. Loving the Chad Morris effect.
BTW the names of the recruits that wanted it to be kept down low are on the pay boards as ponyscott mentioned.

I don't see anything on Rivals?

Re: Potential Stidham destination that isn't Baylor...

Posted: Sun Dec 14, 2014 7:09 pm
by ebrooks11
We are definitely aware he is available.

Re: Potential Stidham destination that isn't Baylor...

Posted: Sun Dec 14, 2014 7:22 pm
by SMU 86
Chnash318 wrote:
Pony Boss wrote:Most likely not coming to SMU but good to be in the conversation. Loving the Chad Morris effect.
BTW the names of the recruits that wanted it to be kept down low are on the pay boards as ponyscott mentioned.

I don't see anything on Rivals?

It's on Scout.

Re: Potential Stidham destination that isn't Baylor...

Posted: Sun Dec 14, 2014 7:24 pm
by SMU 86
ender3 wrote:For those looking for the tweet, it was @craigsmoak, not @davidsmoak.

There's a lot of noise, nothing concrete.

More like there is a lot of smoke (no pun intended). And where there is smoke there could be fire.

Re: Potential Stidham destination that isn't Baylor...

Posted: Sun Dec 14, 2014 7:36 pm
by ParkyPony
SMU 86 wrote:
Chnash318 wrote:
Pony Boss wrote:Most likely not coming to SMU but good to be in the conversation. Loving the Chad Morris effect.
BTW the names of the recruits that wanted it to be kept down low are on the pay boards as ponyscott mentioned.

I don't see anything on Rivals?

It's on Scout.


I want names!!

Re: Potential Stidham destination that isn't Baylor...

Posted: Sun Dec 14, 2014 7:45 pm
by ender3
SMU 86 wrote:
ender3 wrote:For those looking for the tweet, it was @craigsmoak, not @davidsmoak.

There's a lot of noise, nothing concrete.

More like there is a lot of smoke (no pun intended). And where there is smoke there could be fire.


Looking at the Twitter noise, and at the fact that he took an unofficial to Baylor today...

I'm saying Baylor 90%, Oregon 9%, SMU 1% (if that).

Re: Potential Stidham destination that isn't Baylor...

Posted: Sun Dec 14, 2014 8:27 pm
by Oldmins
Can't help but think that this guy, though good, won't be the savior of any program. Remember just a couple of years back when Aledo's Jonathan Gray was the No. 1 high school football player in the US? He could do anything, anywhere, and after heavy recruiting, decided to be the one to make the U of Texas a national champion. Well, how's that gone? He's a starter, to be sure, but only their second best runner behind Brown, and that's not saying much. No one player is ever going to make that much difference.

Re: Potential Stidham destination that isn't Baylor...

Posted: Sun Dec 14, 2014 8:37 pm
by DanFreibergerForHeisman
ender3 wrote:Looking at the Twitter noise, and at the fact that he took an unofficial to Baylor today...

I'm saying Baylor 90%, Oregon 9%, SMU 1% (if that).

Yeah, but isn't it great saying SMU 1% isn't just ridiculous anymore?

Re: Potential Stidham destination that isn't Baylor...

Posted: Sun Dec 14, 2014 9:48 pm
by SMU 86
Oldmins wrote:Can't help but think that this guy, though good, won't be the savior of any program. Remember just a couple of years back when Aledo's Jonathan Gray was the No. 1 high school football player in the US? He could do anything, anywhere, and after heavy recruiting, decided to be the one to make the U of Texas a national champion. Well, how's that gone? He's a starter, to be sure, but only their second best runner behind Brown, and that's not saying much. No one player is ever going to make that much difference.

Gray got hurt badly his freshman year. And yes, one player can make a difference. See how much better Clemson played with Watson and how much better SMU player with GG.

Re: Potential Stidham destination that isn't Baylor...

Posted: Sun Dec 14, 2014 9:57 pm
by Alaric
Oldmins wrote:Can't help but think that this guy, though good, won't be the savior of any program. Remember just a couple of years back when Aledo's Jonathan Gray was the No. 1 high school football player in the US? He could do anything, anywhere, and after heavy recruiting, decided to be the one to make the U of Texas a national champion. Well, how's that gone? He's a starter, to be sure, but only their second best runner behind Brown, and that's not saying much. No one player is ever going to make that much difference.


So highly touted HS players don't make an impact in college? Just wanted arification...

Yes. Gray jacked up his knee. He looked great at UT as an 18 yo freshman

Re: Potential Stidham destination that isn't Baylor...

Posted: Sun Dec 14, 2014 9:58 pm
by SoCal_Pony
Oldmins wrote:Can't help but think that this guy, though good, won't be the savior of any program. Remember just a couple of years back when Aledo's Jonathan Gray was the No. 1 high school football player in the US? He could do anything, anywhere, and after heavy recruiting, decided to be the one to make the U of Texas a national champion. Well, how's that gone? He's a starter, to be sure, but only their second best runner behind Brown, and that's not saying much. No one player is ever going to make that much difference.


True, the Top Programs do not rely on simply 1 star athlete, that is why SMU signed 3 NFL caliber RBs in 1 class, 1 of whom went on to the HOF, another who led his team to their 1st SB.

Re: Potential Stidham destination that isn't Baylor...

Posted: Sun Dec 14, 2014 10:01 pm
by SMU 86
Alaric wrote:
Oldmins wrote:Can't help but think that this guy, though good, won't be the savior of any program. Remember just a couple of years back when Aledo's Jonathan Gray was the No. 1 high school football player in the US? He could do anything, anywhere, and after heavy recruiting, decided to be the one to make the U of Texas a national champion. Well, how's that gone? He's a starter, to be sure, but only their second best runner behind Brown, and that's not saying much. No one player is ever going to make that much difference.


So highly touted HS players don't make an impact in college? Just wanted arification...

Yes. Gray jacked up his knee. He looked great at UT as an 18 yo freshman


Right. Again see the impact Gilbert had on the team last year. Night and day difference of the SMU team with and without Gilbert. 1 player can make a difference. No you shouldn't be in a position o only rely on one player but one player can make a difference.

Re: Potential Stidham destination that isn't Baylor...

Posted: Sun Dec 14, 2014 10:01 pm
by fifty
We rely on 1star athletes. Sorry couldn't resist.