Page 3 of 11

Posted: Tue Jul 24, 2007 5:31 pm
by LonghornFan68
jtstang wrote:
mr. pony wrote:I still like "We Cheated Death."

Except that we really haven't. Twenty years after the death penalty and we have one winning season, at 6-5 mind you, to show for it. Death still has the upper hand.


So are these the twilight years of SMU football? Or is this limbo? I'm confused.

Posted: Tue Jul 24, 2007 5:34 pm
by mr. pony
I think we've beat this before, but here goes:

The fact is we are still playing after "death."

And it will be especially appropriate when we go to a bowl/win a title again.

Posted: Tue Jul 24, 2007 5:39 pm
by jtstang
Well it's twenty years later so that's still weak stuff.

Posted: Tue Jul 24, 2007 5:56 pm
by MrMustang1965
jtstang wrote:
mrydel wrote:And you according to your manifesto.

I recall that as well.
Now, now, jt. I still support SMU. I'm just not a sunshiner anymore.

Posted: Tue Jul 24, 2007 6:09 pm
by crazy horse
This definitely sounds like a fundraising campaign and not a "get your butts to the stadium" kind of campaign.

Just another case of people just being cute/creative without really understanding the product, its history or the target audience. Unfortunately this slogan is really neither cute or particularly creative. I suspect if you locked a gaggle of SMU advertising coeds in a room with some adult beverages, this would emerge within the first 15 minutes of brainstorming. I'm sure that would be far less than the Richards Group retainer.

Mustang Mania should be the barometer of all future campaigns. That was an excellent slogan and marketing effort.

Posted: Tue Jul 24, 2007 6:45 pm
by jtstang
MrMustang1965 wrote:
jtstang wrote:
mrydel wrote:And you according to your manifesto.

I recall that as well.
Now, now, jt. I still support SMU. I'm just not a sunshiner anymore.

Yeah I hear you, and I understand changes of heart, but I still recall in your manifesto you saying things like you didn't care anymore, weren't going to spend time or money supporting SMU, and the like. Am I imagining all that? Do we need to dig up that manifesto post?

Posted: Tue Jul 24, 2007 6:52 pm
by ponydawg
crazy horse wrote:This definitely sounds like a fundraising campaign and not a "get your butts to the stadium" kind of campaign.

Just another case of people just being cute/creative without really understanding the product, its history or the target audience. Unfortunately this slogan is really neither cute or particularly creative. I suspect if you locked a gaggle of SMU advertising coeds in a room with some adult beverages, this would emerge within the first 15 minutes of brainstorming. I'm sure that would be far less than the Richards Group retainer.

Mustang Mania should be the barometer of all future campaigns. That was an excellent slogan and marketing effort.


Haha, you guys are ridiculous. The very first post by 65 says it "appears", he doesn't know. I bet our history is in at least one of the tv and radio spots. Just wait a couple of weeks and stop crying. Besides, anything would be better than what we had last year....which was nothing.

Posted: Tue Jul 24, 2007 7:05 pm
by LakeHighlandsPony
Isn't "ponying up" what got Sherwood Blount and Bill Clements in trouble. If the Richards Group is advocating cheating and paying players again..............well .........I LOVE IT.
Somebody "Pony UP" and get Ron Meyer on the phone and get some 4 star recruits to drive maroon trans-am's from College Station to University Park..PONY UP!


Sherwood Blount and Sherwood,Arkansas-Is there a connection?

Posted: Tue Jul 24, 2007 7:13 pm
by smupony94
ponydawg wrote:
crazy horse wrote:This definitely sounds like a fundraising campaign and not a "get your butts to the stadium" kind of campaign.

Just another case of people just being cute/creative without really understanding the product, its history or the target audience. Unfortunately this slogan is really neither cute or particularly creative. I suspect if you locked a gaggle of SMU advertising coeds in a room with some adult beverages, this would emerge within the first 15 minutes of brainstorming. I'm sure that would be far less than the Richards Group retainer.

Mustang Mania should be the barometer of all future campaigns. That was an excellent slogan and marketing effort.


Haha, you guys are ridiculous. The very first post by 65 says it "appears", he doesn't know. I bet our history is in at least one of the tv and radio spots. Just wait a couple of weeks and stop crying. Besides, anything would be better than what we had last year....which was nothing.


65 is a SHSU graduate who hangs around the SMU campus on a daily basis so that says quite a bit

Posted: Tue Jul 24, 2007 8:02 pm
by PonySoprano
I agree that we don't know if this is the final version of our fall campaign.

However, if "Pony Up" turns out to be the actual campaign, that confirms my belief that Richard Sweet was just mailing it in while he was waiting for the opportunity to run back to SWA.

Posted: Tue Jul 24, 2007 8:07 pm
by Stallion
"PayRoll II Meet"
as in Part Deux

Posted: Tue Jul 24, 2007 8:11 pm
by Diamond Girl
If 'Pony up' doesn't go over well in the AD, maybe it could be used for sustentation.

Posted: Tue Jul 24, 2007 8:20 pm
by MrMustang1965
jtstang wrote:
MrMustang1965 wrote:
jtstang wrote:
mrydel wrote:And you according to your manifesto.

I recall that as well.
Now, now, jt. I still support SMU. I'm just not a sunshiner anymore.

Yeah I hear you, and I understand changes of heart, but I still recall in your manifesto you saying things like you didn't care anymore, weren't going to spend time or money supporting SMU, and the like. Am I imagining all that? Do we need to dig up that manifesto post?
Nope. No need to dig it up. I've got it archived. I'm still a 'fan'. I'm just more realistic about it than I was in previous years. You showed me the light, jt. Take a bow.

Posted: Tue Jul 24, 2007 8:27 pm
by PK
MrMustang1965 wrote:I'm still a 'fan'. I'm just more realistic about it than I was in previous years. You showed me the light, jt. Take a bow.
Does that mean you are going to buy endzone seats and then sit in mrydel's seats????

Posted: Tue Jul 24, 2007 8:30 pm
by MrMustang1965
PK wrote:
MrMustang1965 wrote:I'm still a 'fan'. I'm just more realistic about it than I was in previous years. You showed me the light, jt. Take a bow.
Does that mean you are going to buy endzone seats and then sit in mrydel's seats????
Perhaps.