If I havenΓÇÖt made it clear, let me do so now. The behavior of much of the media, but especially the New York Times, was a disgrace. I donΓÇÖt believe it ever will recover the public trust it squandered.The TimesΓÇÖ previous reputation for having the highest standards was legitimate. Those standards were developed over decades to force reporters and editors to be fair and to gain public trust. The commitment to fairness made the New York Times the flagship of American journalism.
I say this with great sadness. I was blessed to grow up at the Times, getting a clerical job right out of college and working my way onto the reporting staff, where I worked for a decade. It was the formative experience of my career where I learned most of what I know about reporting and writing. Alas, it was a different newspaper then. Abe Rosenthal was the editor in those days, and long before weΓÇÖd ever heard the phrase ΓÇ£zero tolerance,ΓÇ¥ thatΓÇÖs what Abe practiced toward conflicts of interest and reportersΓÇÖ opinions. He set the rules and everybody knew it.
Here is a true story about how Abe Rosenthal resolved a conflict of interest. A young woman was hired by the Times from one of the Philadelphia newspapers. But soon after she arrived in New York, a story broke in Philly that she had had a romantic affair with a political figure she had covered, and that she had accepted a fur coat and other expensive gifts from him. When he saw the story, Abe called the woman into his office and asked her if it was true. When she said yes, he told her to clean out her desk ΓÇö that she was finished at the Times and would never work there again. As word spread through the newsroom, some reporters took the womanΓÇÖs side and rushed in to tell Abe that firing her was too harsh. He listened for about 30 seconds and said, in so many words, ΓÇ£I donΓÇÖt care if you fΓÇôk an elephant on your personal time, but then you canΓÇÖt cover the circus for the paper.ΓÇ¥ Case closed. The conflict-of-interest policy was clear, absolute, and unforgettable.
As for reportersΓÇÖ opinions, Abe had a similar approach. He didnΓÇÖt want them in the news pages. And if you put them in, he took them out. They belonged in the opinion pages only, which were managed separately. Abe said he knew reporters tended to lean left and would find ways to sneak their views into the stories. So he saw his job as steering the paper slightly to the right. ΓÇ£That way,ΓÇ¥ he said, ΓÇ£the paper would end up in the middle.ΓÇ¥ He was well known for this attitude, which he summed up as ΓÇ£keeping the paper straight.ΓÇ¥ He even said he wanted his epitaph to read, ΓÇ£He kept the paper straight.ΓÇ¥ Like most people, I thought this was a joke. But after I related all this in a column last year, his widow contacted me and said it wasnΓÇÖt a joke ΓÇö that, in fact, AbeΓÇÖs tombstone reads, ΓÇ£He kept the paper straight.ΓÇ¥ She sent me a picture to prove it. I published that picture of his tombstone alongside a column where I excoriated the Times for its election coverage. Sadly, the TimesΓÇÖ high standards were buried with Abe Rosenthal.
Good read by Michael Goodman of the New York Post https://nypost.com/2017/07/01/why-the-media-has-broken-down-in-the-age-of-trump/
