Heisman

[George S. Patton]

Good points General. Do you think Dixon would be seriously in the mix had he not been injured?

I think if Oregon was playing in the BCS title game, Dixon would have been the overwhelming choice.

As for Felix Jones outrushing McFadden, that's fine. I think McFadden still rushed for about 1,700 yards and he tore through South Carolina on ESPN and played awesome against Alabama on national TV.

As for Tebow, he was a stud because he is a great rushing quarterback and very talented, but he imploded against LSU, didn't beat Georgia and was very average against Auburn.

[FordtoTolbert]

Stallion...we FINALLY agree on something! Who is your NEW coach pick, btw?

[QuikSStang]

Good points General. Do you think Dixon would be seriously in the mix had he not been injured?

I think if Oregon was playing in the BCS title game, Dixon would have been the overwhelming choice.

i agree with you on dixon. he would have been the runaway winner if he would have stayed healthy and led his team to the BCS championship

[91Stang]

Do you think Dixon would be seriously in the mix had he not been injured?

Should be. Oregon's offense became extraordinarily ordinary after he got hurt.

[SMUMan02]

yea timmy t's gonna get it

He should. I just hope the voters don't look past him because he is a soph.

[QuikSStang]

yea timmy t's gonna get it

He should. I just hope the voters don't look past him because he is a soph.

agreed, but history is against him pretty bad

[SMUMan02]

yea timmy t's gonna get it

He should. I just hope the voters don't look past him because he is a soph.

agreed, but history is against him pretty bad

I think you are right. Almost insurmountably against him.

[Pony Soup]

I think i would vote McFadden or Dixon because I dont like the idea of a soph winning, sorry Timmy. On another note, Dallas Griffin of Texas won the academic heisman, the Draddy Trophy, this week. He was their starting center but tore his ACL in the game against Okla State.

4.0 in 6 out of 8 semesters is pretty solid - better than I ever did.

[Pony Soup]

ESPN is making a pretty solid case for McFadden right now. I think he will probably win tonight

[QuikSStang]

they said 96% of the votes are in. so somebody's won it

[mrydel]

McFadden had some badly bruised ribs he played through during the middle of the season. That probably hurt him enough (pun intended) to cost him the Heisman. He is as good as I have seen since ED.

[J.T.supporta]

the winner will all depend on how the west coast voters vote....as much as i dont want to see an underclass win it...i think he mite...but dont count out mcfadden