Everyone was pumping McCarron this week and the 99 yd TD pass looked like his "Heisman Moment" until Saint Nick lost his mind and attempted a 57 yd FG with disastrous results.
I don't think you can give it to a guy who might be charged with rape the week after he accepts the award. Maybe not fair to him (absolutely not fair to him if he's not guilty, and a travesty) but that's the reality of the situation right now.
Manziel maybe by default but he hasn't been outstanding this year. The BC running back? I honestly don't know. Weirdest Heisman campaign I can remember.