Ok, maybe not the masses, but the guys on Rivals BB message board are very knowledgeable of the game and most are not homers in the true sense of the word. Anyway, each week a guy posts pick'em games of the week and they bold which team they think will win. Click on the link and go to the bottom for the games for this week. SMU/Cincy is one of them. I think you might be surprised.
http://collegebasketball.rivals.com/sho ... 46&style=2
Here is what one of them said:
Cincy v SMU unbeatable at home