A True SMU Recruiting story

papawasamustang · Post by **papawasamustang** » Mon Dec 24, 2007 9:21 am

This happened just a few years ago.

A local honor roll student athlete. State heavyweight wrestling champ, 1st team all district offensive & defensive lineman. 6"3" 300 lbs.

Family ties to SMU. Family ties communicates student athlete accomplishments to SMU recruiting football coordinator never getting a reply from university. Family ties repeats procedure never to hear back again.

Local student athlete gets many offers, none from SMU. Student athlete would love to attend SMU. However, interest is obviously not mutual.

Local student athlete commits & signs with competing school Rice.
Goes on to be First Team All Wac & nominated for Outland Trophy.

Moral of the story. SMU needs to improve recruiting. Although all the focus is on the new HC the $$ also needs to be thrown @ the best recruiter in America.

I remain loyal although its hard watching what's going on @ the Hilltop.

DiamondM75 · Post by **DiamondM75** » Mon Dec 24, 2007 10:53 am

Did student athelete attend Bennetts Camp? If no, then end of story.

Ponymon · Post by **Ponymon** » Mon Dec 24, 2007 10:55 am

papawasamustang wrote:This happened just a few years ago.

A local honor roll student athlete. State heavyweight wrestling champ, 1st team all district offensive & defensive lineman. 6"3" 300 lbs.

Family ties to SMU. Family ties communicates student athlete accomplishments to SMU recruiting football coordinator never getting a reply from university. Family ties repeats procedure never to hear back again.

Local student athlete gets many offers, none from SMU. Student athlete would love to attend SMU. However, interest is obviously not mutual.

Local student athlete commits & signs with competing school Rice.
Goes on to be First Team All Wac & nominated for Outland Trophy.

Moral of the story. SMU needs to improve recruiting. Although all the focus is on the new HC the $$ also needs to be thrown @ the best recruiter in America.

I remain loyal although its hard watching what's going on @ the Hilltop.

One of the many reasons we needed a change! Obviously he did not attend one of PB's camps so he never would have been recruited. :roll:

FordtoTolbert · Post by **FordtoTolbert** » Mon Dec 24, 2007 1:20 pm

Dark to Blasingame to Musial...sounds way to simple, easy, clean..what is the "rest of the story", what are you leaving out? I used to coach high school baseball back in the early 80's, wish I had $1 for every "let me tell you what the UT baseball coaching staff did to my all-state kid...."

papawasamustang · Post by **papawasamustang** » Mon Dec 24, 2007 1:49 pm

There really is no rest of the story.

Just poor recruiting. I'd almost call it just plain lazy. Hard to understand the lack of response. Not even a Thank you reply or anything.

He had several really good choices & the Rice thing worked out well for him.

No sour grapes. He received a great education @ Rice.

My point is in addition to a quality HC, SMU really needs to get a very good recruiting coord.
Looking @ past recruiting classes its easy to see why the records have been what they are.

Junior · Post by **Junior** » Tue Dec 25, 2007 1:39 pm

Does this recruit have a name?

FordtoTolbert · Post by **FordtoTolbert** » Tue Dec 25, 2007 5:50 pm

Coaches, especially assist. are like hound dogs at a fish fry man, if there is / was some stud kid with SMU ties, somebody, someone would have been on this kid like white on rice, especially considering the recruiting climate on the hilltop the last "x" years...nice story, not buying it...

Junior · Post by **Junior** » Tue Dec 25, 2007 5:55 pm

Yeah.

papawasamustang · Post by **papawasamustang** » Tue Dec 25, 2007 6:11 pm

Not asking anybody to buy it.
Its the plain & simple truth. Alot of people like to think there's more to things when there's really not.
Its obvious why the record is what it is, bad, lazy recruiting.

FordtoTolbert · Post by **FordtoTolbert** » Tue Dec 25, 2007 9:21 pm

Where was this "story" 2-3 years ago?? Why belly up to the bar now?

Pony Up · Post by **Pony Up** » Wed Dec 26, 2007 1:05 am

Good god, quit dogpiling Coach Bennett. He's gone. Time for someone new. The lingering hate for the man is nothing more than sad.

It's a shame that we lost a guy with SMU ties, but damn, it happens everywhere at some point.

Cadillac · Post by **Cadillac** » Wed Dec 26, 2007 12:18 pm

papawasamustang wrote:Not asking anybody to buy it.
Its the plain & simple truth. Alot of people like to think there's more to things when there's really not.
Its obvious why the record is what it is, bad, lazy recruiting.

I think FtT was implying that there's less to the story, not more to it.

-CoS

EastStang · Post by **EastStang** » Wed Dec 26, 2007 3:25 pm

I agree that Bennett is now gone, and he's not in charge of recruiting anymore. Whatever system he used worked for awhile, but in the end, we were 1-11 this year. Let's just put the last six years behind us as a noble experiement that did not work out.

Chuck Norris · Post by **Chuck Norris** » Thu Dec 27, 2007 10:54 am

Pony Up wrote:Good god, quit dogpiling Coach Bennett. He's gone. Time for someone new. The lingering hate for the man is nothing more than sad.

It's a shame that we lost a guy with SMU ties, but damn, it happens everywhere at some point.

Is it okay to bash the idiots who are in charge of recruiting??? I really hope Orsini cleans house

papawasamustang · Post by **papawasamustang** » Fri Dec 28, 2007 10:06 am

my point is that SMU has to do a better job of recruiting.
Although we all think they are contacting ALL the local kids that make good grades & can play some ball, they DON'T.

The whole point is in addition to a good new head coach, a good new recruiting coordinator is also very much needed. Can't continue to make the small east Tx schools your hotbed for recruiting.

A True SMU Recruiting story

A True SMU Recruiting story

Re: A True SMU Recruiting story