I hate the CFP committee

[highlander]

Ohio St loses at home to an unranked Michigan team, in the last week of the season, and they only drop 4 spots (2 to 6).

This has all the elements that you normally look for in a big drop in the rankings:
- home loss to an unranked team
- last week of the season
- the team has a strong incentive to win: conf championship game appearance

[Dukie]

Ohio St loses at home to an unranked Michigan team, in the last week of the season, and they only drop 4 spots (2 to 6).

This has all the elements that you normally look for in a big drop in the rankings:
- home loss to an unranked team
- last week of the season
- the team has a strong incentive to win: conf championship game appearance

You are, of course, not wrong. But the situation is as the situation has been. Win. Beat Clemson. ThatΓÇÖs the way.

[mustang1992]

Think how different this would look today had GT>GEO, MIA > SYR, CLE >SC. All were right there for the taking. ACC would be sitting with 3 clearly in. Sigh....

[Dukie]

Think how different this would look today had GT>GEO, MIA > SYR, CLE >SC. All were right there for the taking. ACC would be sitting with 3 clearly in. Sigh....

This is also true.

[PonyPride]

SMU now No. 8

[planoponyfan]

It's pretty clear from the comments of the committee chair that SMU must win the ACC Championship to get in. They will take a 3 loss Alabama team over a 2 loss SMU team.

Okay, so go beat Clemson and settle this. I'm fine with that.

[Charleston Pony]

Yes; SMU needs to beat a "brand name" team and Clemson is one of those!

[Graceland Tar Heel]

Ohio St loses at home to an unranked Michigan team, in the last week of the season, and they only drop 4 spots (2 to 6).

This has all the elements that you normally look for in a big drop in the rankings:
- home loss to an unranked team
- last week of the season
- the team has a strong incentive to win: conf championship game appearance

Compare that to Miami, which lost on range road to a team that finished 9-3. Miami is below Bama now.

The whole system is basically arranged for the SEC and BT.

[indianmustang]

setting up SMU to Drop if we dont win

https://x.com/JTalty/status/1864111067653157352

[highlander]

setting up SMU to Drop if we dont win

https://x.com/JTalty/status/1864111067653157352

An exhaustive 10-second google search has revealed that, not only is Warde Manuel the CFP Committee Chair, but he also moonlights as Michigan's AD!

[Dukie]

setting up SMU to Drop if we dont win

https://x.com/JTalty/status/1864111067653157352

An exhaustive 10-second google search has revealed that, not only is Warde Manuel the CFP Committee Chair, but he also moonlights as Michigan's AD!

It will be up to the UVa AD this year to do what the NC State AD failed to do last year and defend the conference effectively.

Also, I read his comments as saying if SMU gets blown out in Charlotte, weΓÇÖre out. But I do agree we could be out regardless.

[highlander]

I didn't realize the committee was comprised of ADs.

[highlander]

It should be comprised of a bunch of foreign soccer fans who know nothing about American College Football but are really good at comparing numbers and analyzing data.

[indianmustang]

It should be comprised of a bunch of foreign soccer fans who know nothing about American College Football but are really good at comparing numbers and analyzing data.

Maybe Allocate slots for each league based on last 4 years performance

[Dukie]

I didn't realize the committee was comprised of ADs.

Like the NCAA MBB D1 Committee, it's broader than that. And I'll add to my previous statement about UVa AD Carla Williams to say that Jim Grobe should stick up for the ACC as well, and it will be hard to talk about Nevada being a weak win for SMU with Chris Ault sitting in the room.

The 13:

Four are former coaches:

ΓÇó Gary Pinkel, most notably MissouriΓÇÖs coach from 2001-15.

ΓÇó Mike Riley, Oregon State and Nebraska coaching stints and played for Bear Bryant at Alabama.

ΓÇó Jim Grobe, longtime Wake Forest coach and before that Ohio.

ΓÇó Chris Ault, NevadaΓÇÖs coach for 23 years.

Two more members are notable former players:

ΓÇó Randall McDaniel, All-Pro Minnesota Vikings offensive lineman who played at Arizona State from 1984-87.

ΓÇó Will Shields, Pro Football Hall of Famer who played guard for the Kansas City Chiefs and played at Nebraska.

Six members are sitting athletic directors:

ΓÇó Michigan's Warde Manuel (chair).

ΓÇó UVa's Carla Williams (at UGA from 2016-2020 though).

ΓÇó ArkansasΓÇÖ Hunter Yurachek.

ΓÇó NavyΓÇÖs Chet Gladchuk.

ΓÇó BaylorΓÇÖs Mack Rhoades.

ΓÇó Miami of OhioΓÇÖs David Sayler.

Finally, there is a former media member:

ΓÇó Kelly Whiteside, who covered college football for USA Today for 14 years and was the first female president of the Football Writers Association of America.